Common Law Marriage: Meaning, Requirements & Legal Implications

Imagine getting married, saying your vows, and seeing the person you love become your partner for life.

Aside from traditional marriage, there is also common law marriage.

Common law marriage adds complexity to modern relationships. Only a few people understand how it works and what complexities it holds.

Kimberly Smith, LMHC, says

Couples choose common-law marriages, allowing the freedom to define their love and bond on their own terms, where commitment is measured not by rings and a marriage license, but by the depth of their shared journey and the resilience of their union.

Let’s unravel the complexities, challenges, and joys of forging a lasting bond outside traditional marriage.

How do you define common law marriage?

What is a common law status in marriage?

Common law marriage is a form of legal recognition where a couple is considered married despite not undergoing a formal ceremony due to their long-term cohabitation and mutual intent to be spouses.

This union typically involves living together, sharing finances, and presenting themselves as a married couple.

While specific requirements vary by jurisdiction, common elements include a shared residence, a public declaration of partnership, and a sustained commitment.

Despite lacking a marriage license, couples in common-law marriages often enjoy legal rights akin to traditionally married spouses, highlighting the different ways relationships are recognized and validated within the legal landscape.

What is the difference between a common law marriage and a traditional marriage?

Common law marriage and traditional marriage differ primarily in how they are formed and recognized.

In a traditional marriage, a couple typically undergoes a formal ceremony, secures a marriage license, and fulfills legal requirements.

In contrast, a common law marriage is established through prolonged cohabitation and mutual intent to be spouses without a formal ceremony.

What are the requirements for a common-law marriage?

If you want to know the requirements for a common law marriage, the answer would vary by jurisdiction but typically involve consistent cohabitation and a mutual agreement to consider oneself married. 

While a formal common law marriage certificate is not always required, meeting specific criteria establishes the validity of the union. 

Key elements include

• A shared residence where the couple lives.
• A public declaration of the partnership.
• A sustained commitment to the relationship.

It’s crucial to understand that not all states recognize common-law marriage, and those that do may have different criteria. 

For legal documentation, couples may opt for a common law marriage certificate, providing tangible proof of their commitment in jurisdictions that accept such documentation.

What are the legal implications of a common-law marriage?

The question of “common law marriage how long” hinges on individual state laws; for instance, some states mandate several years of cohabitation. 

By this time, the couple should be fully aware of the implications of common-law marriage. 

1. Property rights

Common law marriage property may be distributed equitably without a formal agreement, affecting asset division during separation.

2. Inheritance

Depending on state laws and union duration, common-law spouses may have inheritance rights like married couples.

3. Spousal support

Spousal support may apply in common-law marriages with financial dependency.

4. Child custody and support

The legal responsibilities regarding children from the union, including custody and support, can mirror those of traditional marriages.

5. Healthcare and insurance benefits

Some states extend healthcare and insurance benefits to common-law spouses, providing access to crucial services.

6. Tax implications

Common law spouses may face different tax considerations that impact filing status, deductions, and credits.

7. End-of-life decision-making

In the absence of legal documentation, common-law spouses may need help making critical end-of-life decisions for each other.

8. Recognition across states

The legal status of common law marriages can vary significantly between states, potentially affecting rights and obligations if the couple relocates.

9. Duration matters

How long is common law marriage retained before it’s recognized? Common law marriages are recognized based on cohabitation duration, which varies by state.

10. Legal documentation

While not all states issue a common law marriage certificate, couples may choose legal alternatives like domestic partnership registration to solidify their commitment and rights.

How is common law marriage recognized across different jurisdictions?

Is common law marriage legal? Or which are the states that allow common law marriage? Those are some common questions that people ask.

The recognition of common law marriage varies across different jurisdictions, and it’s essential to understand the specific laws of each location. 

Here’s an overview of common law marriage states:

1. State-specific laws in the U.S.

Common law marriage is a state-level matter in the United States. While some states fully recognize and validate common-law marriages, others do not recognize them at all. 

Currently, 7 states in the US recognize common-law marriages: Texas, Utah, Montana, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Iowa, and Kansas.

Common law marriage in California was no longer being recognized within its borders after 1895. 

So, why was common law marriage abolished in California? 

The reason why common law marriage was abolished was because they considered it confusing and inefficient. 

However, if a common law marriage was validly established in another jurisdiction before a specific date, California will recognize it. 

Other states that recognize common-law marriages before a specific date include (but not limited to), Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Alabama, and others.

2. International variations

Recognition of common law marriage extends beyond the United States, with some countries acknowledging such unions. 

However, the criteria and legal consequences can vary widely. Couples must research and understand the laws of the specific country or jurisdiction in which they reside.

3. Choice of law agreements

Sometimes, couples may establish a “choice of law” agreement, specifying which jurisdiction’s laws govern their relationship. This is common when partners move frequently or have ties to different regions.

4. Full Faith and Credit

In the U.S., the Constitution’s Full Faith and Credit Clause generally requires states to recognize legal decisions made in other states. 

However, this principle doesn’t always extend to common law marriages, and some states may not fully honor the legal status granted in another jurisdiction.

5. Recognition through legal alternatives

In places where common law marriage is not recognized, couples often seek legal alternatives such as registering as domestic partners or entering into a formal marriage to secure legal recognition and rights.

6. Common law marriage agreements

Some couples may create written agreements explicitly stating their commitment and the terms of their common law marriage. While not universally recognized, these documents can prove the couple’s intent and understanding.

Couples in common law marriages must know their jurisdiction’s legal landscape and take proactive steps to ensure their relationship is recognized and protected. 

Seeking legal advice and formalizing their commitment through alternative legal means can be valuable in navigating these complexities.

Do you think you’re being codependent with your partner? Maybe it’s the other way around. Let Doc Snipes, a clinical psychotherapist, unveil the effects of codependency for you:

FAQs

There is still so much to learn about common-law marriage, and these questions can provide more insight.

• What is the difference between common-law marriage and registered domestic partnership?

Common-law marriage is a union formed through prolonged cohabitation and mutual intent, recognized in some jurisdictions based on specific criteria.

In contrast, a registered domestic partnership is a legally recognized relationship, often with fewer requirements than marriage, providing certain rights and responsibilities.

While common-law marriage relies on informal conduct, a domestic partnership involves a formal registration process with the state.

• Is common-law marriage recognized in all states?

Are there states that allow common-law marriage? Is common law marriage legal?

Yes, there are, but not all of them. Common-law marriage is not recognized in all states in the United States.

Colorado or CO common law marriage has been recognized as legal and binding since 1877. It’s one of the 12 states that do so. The specific criteria and requirements for recognition also vary between states that acknowledge this form of union.

• What are the benefits of common-law marriage?

Common-law marriage can offer various benefits, including shared property rights, inheritance privileges, and eligibility for spousal support.

It allows couples to enjoy legal recognition without a formal ceremony. Additionally, common-law spouses may access healthcare and insurance benefits, and in some cases, they share tax advantages.

However, the benefits depend on the jurisdiction, and couples must meet specific criteria. Understanding the relevant state’s laws is essential to fully appreciating the advantages of common-law marriage.

• What are some of the drawbacks of common-law marriage?

Drawbacks of common-law marriage include legal uncertainty, as not all states recognize it, potentially leading to issues if the couple relocates.

Property division can become complex, especially if an explicit agreement is needed. Additionally, common-law spouses may lack certain federal benefits available to formally married couples.

To mitigate these challenges, couples might consider legal alternatives, like formal marriage or domestic partnership registration.

• How can you prove a common-law marriage?

Proving common-law marriage typically involves presenting evidence of cohabitation, mutual intent, and a public acknowledgment of the relationship.

Documentation such as joint bank accounts, shared bills, or testimonies from friends and family can support the claim.

While it can be challenging, demonstrating the elements required by the specific state’s laws increases the likelihood of successfully proving the existence of a common-law marriage.

Take an informed decision

Common-law marriage presents a unique avenue for couples to establish legal recognition without a formal ceremony.

While offering benefits like shared property rights and inheritance privileges, its drawbacks include legal uncertainties and potential complications in property division.

Proving common-law marriage hinges on providing evidence of cohabitation and mutual intent.

Given the variances in recognition across states, couples should carefully consider the legal landscape and may opt for alternative legal arrangements for added clarity.

Understanding the complexities ensures that couples can navigate the intricacies of common-law marriage, making informed decisions about their relationships.